Special order items have messages in Red for deliverability

Free Shipping

Free Shipping Over $100 inside Continental US

Just in Time for Halloween

10% Off Site Wide

BeSpooky2026

Fantasy Stocking Stuffers

(306 products)
View as

Looking for just the right little thing to slip into a Christmas stocking this holiday season? We've got some really awesome suggestions for you! These items may be small, but that pack a punch and will make an impression on your friends, loved ones, and anyone lucky enough to receive them!

Here, you'll find fantasy favorites to suit all hobbies and interests. We've got gaming accessories like dice for D&D, playing cards, and small tabletop games. There's jewelry - a classic and timeless gift - earrings, necklaces and the like. Small figurines are a unique option to tuck into a stocking, or opt for stationery and paper goods, handy for jotting down notes!

These items are also good options for host and hostess gifts, party favors, and other times when something small but special is required.

And, as with so many of our gift items, we feature the art of greats like Ruth Thompson, Amy Brown, Nene Thomas, Laurie Prindle, Frank Frazetta, Lisa Parker, and so many more!

  • Free Shipping

    When you spend $100+
    Continental US Only

  • Ask Us Anything

    24-hour email info@FairyGlen.com

  • Mon-Fri 9 to 5 EST

    +1 (973) 653-5147

  • Gift Certificates

    For your loved one, in any amount
Back to top